TRACE · ROUND 3

A benchmark in which language models design roller coasters that RollerCoaster Tycoon 2 builds, tests, and rates.

claude-opus-5-5 · 20260922-opus55-design-full · round 3 back to model →
events
24
tool calls
19
rejected
0
session
0:00
Session trace
  1. ToolSearch
    {"max_results":10,"query":"select:mcp__coaster__new_ride,mcp__coaster__place_pieces,mcp__coaster__get_state,mcp__coaster__finish_and_test,mcp__coaster__valid_next_pieces,mcp__coaster__piece_geometry,mcp__coaster__undo_piece,mcp__coaster__demolish,mcp__coaster__best_result,mcp__coaster__place_piece"}
  2. new_ride
    {"dir":2,"ride_type":51,"x":40,"y":60}
    {"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"ride_id":0}
  3. place_pieces
    {"pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":25,"t":"booster"},{"speed":25,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","up_25","up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25","down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":22,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat",{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_2… (1356 chars)
    {"circuit_closed":true,"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"placed_this_call":70,"total_placed":70}
  4. I lowered booster speeds slightly (24→22, 22→20) to trim intensity.

  5. finish_and_test
    {"bounds":{"max_tile_x":64,"max_tile_y":75,"max_z":344,"min_tile_x":38,"min_tile_y":55,"min_z":112},"placed_pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":25,"t":"booster"},{"speed":25,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","up_25","up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25","down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":22,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_lo… (2224 chars)
  6. piece_geometry
    {"dir":2}
    {"deltas":[{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":0,"piece":"flat","slope_out":0},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":0,"piece":"end_station","slope_out":0},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":0,"piece":"begin_station","slope_out":0},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":0,"piece":"middle_station","slope_out":0},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":16,"piece":"up_25","slope_out":2},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":64,"piece":"up_60","slope_out":4},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":8,"piece":"flat_to_up_25","slope_out":2},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":32,"piece":"up_25_to_up_60","slope_out":4},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":32,"piece":"up_60_to_up_25","slope_out":2},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":8,"piece":"up_25_to_flat","slope_out":0},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":-16,"piece":"down_25","slope_out":6},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"dy_tiles":0,"dz":-64,"piece":"down_60","slope_out":8},{"bank_out":0,"dir_out":2,"dx_tiles":1,"d… (7346 chars)
  7. new_ride
    {"dir":2,"ride_type":51,"x":40,"y":60}
    {"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"ride_id":0}
  8. place_pieces
    {"pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":25,"t":"booster"},{"speed":25,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat"]}
    {"circuit_closed":false,"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":3,"slope":0,"x":64,"y":63,"z":112},"placed_this_call":39,"total_placed":39}
  9. place_pieces
    {"pieces":["flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":22,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat",{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat","flat",{"speed":4,"t":"brakes"},"right_turn_3","flat","right_turn_3"]}
    {"circuit_closed":true,"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"placed_this_call":29,"total_placed":68}
  10. finish_and_test
    {"bounds":{"max_tile_x":67,"max_tile_y":75,"max_z":344,"min_tile_x":38,"min_tile_y":55,"min_z":112},"placed_pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":25,"t":"booster"},{"speed":25,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":22,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop",… (2255 chars)
  11. new_ride
    {"dir":2,"ride_type":51,"x":40,"y":60}
    {"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"ride_id":0}
  12. place_pieces
    {"pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":19,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat",{"speed":18,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to… (1352 chars)
    {"circuit_closed":true,"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"placed_this_call":68,"total_placed":68}
  13. I've banked 6.72 already. Now I'm testing a version with extra corkscrews and slower boosters to bring intensity down.

  14. finish_and_test
    {"bounds":{"max_tile_x":67,"max_tile_y":75,"max_z":344,"min_tile_x":38,"min_tile_y":55,"min_z":112},"placed_pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":19,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop",… (2267 chars)
  15. The new best is 6.94. Intensity is 10.22, a bit over the limit, so I'm trimming booster speeds a little more.

  16. new_ride
    {"dir":2,"ride_type":51,"x":40,"y":60}
    {"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"ride_id":0}
  17. place_pieces
    {"pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":18,"t":"booster"},{"speed":18,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":18,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat",{"speed":17,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to… (1352 chars)
    {"circuit_closed":true,"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"placed_this_call":68,"total_placed":68}
  18. finish_and_test
    {"bounds":{"max_tile_x":67,"max_tile_y":75,"max_z":344,"min_tile_x":38,"min_tile_y":55,"min_z":112},"placed_pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":18,"t":"booster"},{"speed":18,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":18,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop",… (2267 chars)
  19. That scored lower (6.87). One more try: keep the first boosters at 20 and raise the last one for more airtime on the final hills.

  20. new_ride
    {"dir":2,"ride_type":51,"x":40,"y":60}
    {"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"ride_id":0}
  21. place_pieces
    {"pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":19,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat",{"speed":22,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to… (1352 chars)
    {"circuit_closed":true,"cursor":{"bank":0,"dir":2,"slope":0,"x":40,"y":60,"z":112},"placed_this_call":68,"total_placed":68}
  22. finish_and_test
    {"bounds":{"max_tile_x":67,"max_tile_y":75,"max_z":344,"min_tile_x":38,"min_tile_y":55,"min_z":112},"placed_pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":19,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop",… (2265 chars)
  23. best_result
    {"bounds":{"max_tile_x":67,"max_tile_y":75,"max_z":344,"min_tile_x":38,"min_tile_y":55,"min_z":112},"placed_pieces":["begin_station","middle_station","middle_station","end_station",{"chain":true,"t":"flat_to_up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25"},{"chain":true,"t":"up_25_to_flat"},"left_turn_5","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_down_60","down_60","down_60","down_60_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat","right_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down",{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},{"speed":20,"t":"booster"},"left_corkscrew_up","right_corkscrew_down","right_corkscrew_up","left_corkscrew_down","flat","flat","flat_to_up_25","up_25_to_flat","flat_to_down_25","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_right_bank","banked_right_turn_5","right_bank_to_flat",{"speed":19,"t":"booster"},"flat_to_up_25","left_vertical_loop","down_25_to_flat","flat_to_up_25","right_vertical_loop",… (2267 chars)
  24. My best coaster this round scored **6.94 excitement**, up from 6.72 last round. Intensity is 10.22, just over the ~10 guideline. It's a 68-piece twister with 6 inversions and no crash, and its similarity score is 0.40, under the 0.5 penalty line. - **What changed:** I swapped one of last round's camelback hills for two back-to-back corkscrew pairs (6 inversions in total), then lowered the booster speeds to 20/20/19/18. - **Without the slower boosters it failed:** the same layout at the original booster speeds hit intensity 15.25 and excitement fell to 1.60. - **Other variants:** slowing the boosters further brought intensity to 10.11, but excitement dropped to 6.87. A faster last booster (22) matched 6.94 but pushed intensity up to 10.27.